Printed fromChabadCentral.org
ב"ה

Can we change the past?

Thursday, 18 September, 2008 - 9:15 am

Once I’ve made a mistake, can it ever be retroactively un-done?

Sure, we can make amends and learn for the future.

But can I ever un-speak hurtful words?

Not in the concrete sense.

But there’s more to life than the concrete.

Regret is a multi-level experience.

Sometimes, we rue our behavior because we don’t like the fallout. When you’ve hurt someone important, and the relationship has become uncomfortable, you say you're sorry.

Why? Because you want the pain to go away.

That's regret; but it's not transformative remorse.

It's ‘relationship management’.

Why? Because you haven’t experienced genuine character change.

You’re uncomfortable with the REACTION, not the action itself; you’re modifying your behavior based on someone else's response, not your own principles.

Real change doesn't happen that way.

Even when it's inspired by something external, real transformation needs to spring from within.

Transformative regret needs to be holistic.

I believe that G-d created me with the capacity to be a true mentsch, with character and integrity.

I have to envision that potential as my gold standard.

Every day, I need to measure my behavior against that potential.

Because I want to do better.

Not because of you.

Because of me.

Because of my destiny.

I care about others’ hurt feelings. And I need to deal with them. But my rehabilitation starts with me.

Your displeasure is helpful; it alerts me to a possible character-misalignment. When I’ve searched and recalibrated myself in a serious way, you’ll know.

Because I’ll express it.

In a genuine way.

Because it flows from me.

In the scope of my life, I can transform this mistake into a shining moment of growth and self-improvement.

No, I can’t control people’s memories; I may never be able to undo the past in their minds.

But in my life, between me and G-d, if I’m using my mistakes as powerful springboards for positive change, then I’ve done the impossible.

I’ve reached back in time and transformed a negative event into a positive force for growth.

That’s the way I see it.

I can only pray that you’ll see it this way too.

 

Comments on: Can we change the past?
9/18/2008

Steve Bronski wrote...

As I review the previous day and see that I have harmed someone all I can do is try to make amends. In the process of making the amends I need to realize that they may or may not be accepted graciously or for that matter they may not be accepted at all. I think that I need to understand or accept that some things I cannot undo, but on the otherhand I am compelled to try and do the right thing for my own spiritual growth. If my ammends might do more harm than good I need to keep my mouth shut and wait for another opportunity.
9/18/2008

A wrote...

One answer to your question is that you can not change the past, you can live with it, rationalize it, deal with it, justify it, learn from it and repeat it. I am sure there are 1000's of ways to address the past including forgetting it and moving on or trying to deal with it, including changing oneself and owning it. But the past is there and it can not change. How one wants to move forward is a choice which can be called free will. Alzheimer's can come in handy when dealing with the past, especially in a marriage along with a sense of humor, so you do not go crazy.
9/18/2008

Meryl wrote...

What a wonderful way for a hurt to become a springboard for growth. Too often, there is an automatic "I'm sorry". It feels hollow - it can just be to appease and regain favor, as the Rabbi mentionned. But to truly realize you have sold yourself (and HaShem) short by your action, and to truly change, what a blessing!!
May we all be blessed like that.
9/18/2008

Rachel wrote...

I think what we're saying here is that the most sincere apology comes in the form of changed behavior. The acceptance of an apology is really forgiveness. Sometimes forgiveness takes time. When we hurt, a trust has been broken. Regaining that trust takes time. Observing a consistent and positive change in bahavior builds trust and in so doing allows for forgiveness.
Mendy, you use the words "freedom" and "forgiven" or forgiveness in the same sentence above. Can you elaborate what the Torah says about those two things and how they relate?
9/18/2008

Rachel wrote...

Hmm, maybe you're right - there is a level of forgiveness that can exist before trust is fully restored. Maybe it's not so black and white. I will have to think more about that. Is it possible that we hold on to our anger and resentment as a defense mechanism - to protect us from getting hurt again? I am certainly guilty of holding on to some anger and resentment from time to time, but there is no pleasure in it, I can promise you that....only fear. Either way, you're right, there's no question it's unhealthy.
Interestingly, this whole discussion is leading me back to our other discussion about prayer...I'm still thinking a lot about that and how that dialogue inside and outside myself weaves through and connects everything....
9/11/2023

Thota sriram wrote...

Nice post. I was checking constantly this weblog and I’m impressed!